Sunday, April 6, 2008
For any pyshical effect, there is a physical cause. This is a commonly held belief of anyone whose religious views lie in the physical realm. From this one can deduce that if souls and gods exist, their presence is irrelevant to the physical world. This is the case in that the statement "for any physical effect there is a physical cause rules out the possibility of a physical effect being caused by a non-physical cause. Thus, spirits, souls or even gods being immaterial would count as a non-physical cause and cannot cause any physical event. In this way, the material and immaterial world are divided and are mutually exclusive. There is nothing to say that immaterial thing cannot interact with other immaterial things, but no matter how long this chain goes, it cannot have any impact upon the physical material world. Thus, I find the existance of souls to be irrelevant and I see no reason to believe in them. While this premise is unproven, it seems difficult to conceptualize an immaterial object affecting a material object. An immaterial object cannot exert force or generate heat or force an electric impulse. So if a physical-immaterial interaction of this type could occur, what would be the mechanism through which it is done?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
I'm interested in this because I'm interested the make up of the universe, but since I'm a way-layperson, maybe you can help. I know about string-theory -- not that I understand it. But if string theory "suggests ten or eleven" dimensions (WikiP), could one just say it's all just math? How is this saying the soul doesn't exist because it's unproven.
I guess, it's this kind of confusion that's just plain confusing. For laypeople, can scientists explain the difference between a theory of ten or eleven dimensions and souls?
add "like" after "this" and before "saying"
Well Rik, there is actually a theory called Determinism which basically does say "its all math".
If you'r still interested I will be covering this more in depth in my post next week
What is physical? Nobody even knows what anything is made out of. Strings which make up everything everything are vibrating loops of energy. And they are so small that can only be understood within the realm of quantum mechanics which doesn't resemble the world of physics as we know it. Like Rik said, there are more than 4 dimensions, and probably more than one universe. So even if God or souls lived in the physical realm, there is a good chance that we wouldn't detect it because we barely have any familiarity with the physical world.
Post a Comment